HighlightsKendall Jenner claimed to be the first to wear a 1999 McQueen dress at the 2024 Met Gala.A 1990s photo of Winona Ryder in the same dress challenged Kendall’s claim.A photographer confirmed that the photo of Winona in the dress was authentic, contradicting Givenchy.

On the red carpet at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, USA, Kendall told La La Anthony in an interview withVogue: “I am so, so incredibly honored to wear it.”

Controversy erupted over Kendall Jenner’s Met Gala dress when a 1990s photo of Winona Ryder wearing it surfaced

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Image credits:Gotham/Getty Images

“I am the first human to wear it.

“It was a miracle that it fit. It was a miracle that we found it. It just feels meant to be.”

Constructed of nude and black tulle, the dress is covered with over 100,000 black and brass beads and sequins, which were hand-embroidered over 500 hours,Voguereported on Tuesday (May 7).

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Image credits:Vogue

“Tonight, Jenner becomes the first person to ever wear one of McQueen’s autumn/winter 1999 looks for Givenchy Haute Couture,” thefashionmagazine wrote.

As per the publication, the collection was presented on mannequins and never shown on the runway.

It was claimed Kendall was the first person ever to wear the Givenchy gown, but Winona seemingly wore it in the 1990s

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Image credits:Warwick Saint/LaModeUnknown

The 2024 Met Galacelebrated the Costume Institute’s new exhibition,Sleeping Beauties: Reawakening Fashion,and the official dress code wasThe Garden of Time.

However, after a bombshell picture of actress Winona wearing the same dress in a 1999 magazine shared on the Instagram accountmcqueen_vaultstarted circulating earlier this week, many questions arose.

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Image credits:Giovanni Giannoni/WWD/Penske Media

A person posted the picture of theBeetlejuicestar onX(formerly known as Twitter), asking: “So what’s the tea because Givenchy and Kendall Jenner are both saying this look has never been worn but then this picture of Winona Ryder in it exists?”

The 1999 Alexander McQueen for Givenchy gown is covered with over 100,000 sequins, hand-embroidered over 500 hours

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

A source close to Givenchy toldThe Cuton Tuesday that the dress the Golden Globe award winner wore was a replica and that the McQueen dress on Kendall was, in fact, never worn.

But since then, renowned photographer Warwick Saint took to hisInstagram pageto clarify that he had shot the image of Winona wearing this authentic Givenchy dress back in 1999.

View this post on Instagram

Warwick wrote: “Interestingly,Kendall Jennerclaimed she was the first to wear this dress and a few people have reached out to me asking if it was authentic ~ it definitely was the authentic Givenchy dress for sure.”

Nevertheless, Givenchy toldBuzzfeedon Wednesday (May 8) that Kendall’s dress atthe Met Galahad never been worn before and that Winona’s dress was a replica of the original look.

The nature ofThe Kardashianspersonality’s ball dress is yet to be elucidated, as the ordeal has left the show-biz industry divided.

“I am the first human to wear it,” Kendall toldVogueat the 2024 Met Gala’s red carpet

Actress Zandrea Penn commented on Warwick’s Instagram post: “I’m shocked that the rumor is that the one Winona wore was a replica.

“Could you imagine a replica of a dress that took over 500 hours to hand-embroider 100,000 beads and sequins?

“Why would they make two?”

Another person exclaimed: “Did it first and BETTER.”

The Met Ball dress scandal continued to draw backlash

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Winona Ryder Photo Sparks Debate Over Kendall Jenner’s Claim She Was First In Givenchy Dress

Thanks! Check out the results:

Entertainment